Professional dog trainers have a saying: “You’re only as good as your treats.” A distracted dog at the park won’t work for a piece of dry kibble, but wave a piece of freeze-dried liver and suddenly you have their undivided attention. The best training treats are small (you’ll use dozens per session), smelly (dogs are motivated by scent, not appearance), low-calorie (so you don’t create an obese but well-trained dog), and easy to carry in a pocket without creating a mess.
What Makes a Good Training Treat
- Size: Pea-sized or smaller. The dog should swallow in one second and refocus on you. Large treats slow the training rhythm.
- Smell: Strong-smelling treats outperform bland ones in every training scenario. Liver, fish, and cheese are top motivators.
- Calories: Training sessions can involve 50-100 treats. At 3-5 calories each, that’s 150-500 extra calories — significant for small dogs. Choose low-calorie options.
- Texture: Soft treats are consumed faster than crunchy ones, keeping the training pace brisk. Avoid anything that requires chewing.
- Single ingredient: Fewer ingredients mean fewer potential allergens and stomach upsets.
Top 6 Training Treats
1. Zuke’s Mini Naturals — Best Overall
The industry standard for training treats, and for good reason. Each piece is roughly pea-sized, soft enough to eat instantly, and packs a strong enough smell to hold attention in distracting environments. The chicken recipe leads with real chicken, contains only 3.5 calories per treat, and the resealable bag fits in a jacket pocket. We’ve yet to meet a dog who turns these down.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Perfect size for rapid-fire training | Can dry out if bag isn’t sealed |
| Only 3.5 calories each | Some flavors crumble easily |
| Real meat first ingredient | Not single-ingredient |
| Multiple flavor options | Contains chickpeas |
2. Stewart Freeze-Dried Liver — Best High-Value
When you need maximum motivation — recall training, counter-conditioning, or working around high distractions — freeze-dried beef liver is the nuclear option. Single ingredient, insanely aromatic, and dogs go absolutely bonkers for it. Break each piece into 3-4 smaller bits for training-appropriate sizes. At about 5 calories per full piece (1-2 per broken bit), it’s surprisingly reasonable.
3. Pet Botanics Training Reward — Best Value
At roughly $5 for a 20oz bag containing over 500 treats, Pet Botanics offers the lowest cost per treat of any quality option. Real pork liver is the first ingredient, each treat is 3 calories, and the soft texture maintains training pace. Professional trainers who go through hundreds of treats per week often default to these for budget reasons.
4. Wellness Soft Puppy Bites — Best for Puppies
Puppies have tiny mouths and sensitive stomachs. These grain-free, soft bites are sized specifically for puppies and contain DHA for brain development. Lamb and salmon are the primary proteins. The soft texture is easy on developing teeth, and the lower calorie count (about 3 calories each) means you won’t accidentally overfeed during the intensive training period of puppyhood.
5. Fruitables Skinny Minis — Best Low-Calorie
At just 2.5 calories per treat, Fruitables Skinny Minis are the best option for dogs on a diet who still need training rewards. Made with pumpkin and real fruit, they’re grain-free and wheat-free. The chewy texture and fruity smell appeal to most dogs, though dedicated meat-lovers may find them less motivating than liver-based options.
6. Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Minnows — Best Single-Ingredient
For dogs with allergies or sensitive stomachs, these single-ingredient freeze-dried minnows eliminate guesswork. One ingredient: minnows. The strong fish smell makes them extremely high-value for training, and you can break each minnow into 2-3 pieces. They’re also naturally rich in omega-3s, so your dog’s coat benefits alongside their obedience skills.
Comparison Table
| Treat | Best For | Calories/Treat | Texture | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zuke’s Mini | Overall | 3.5 | Soft | $$ |
| Stewart Liver | High-value | ~2 (broken) | Freeze-dried | $$$ |
| Pet Botanics | Value | 3 | Soft | $ |
| Wellness Puppy | Puppies | 3 | Soft | $$ |
| Fruitables Skinny | Low-calorie | 2.5 | Chewy | $$ |
| Vital Minnows | Single-ingredient | ~2 | Freeze-dried | $$$ |
Frequently Asked Questions
How many treats can I give during a training session?
A 15-20 minute session typically uses 30-60 treats. Reduce your dog’s meal portion accordingly. A common rule: treats should make up no more than 10% of daily calories. For a 30-pound dog eating 800 calories/day, that’s 80 calories in treats — roughly 20-25 Zuke’s Minis.
My dog isn’t food-motivated — what should I do?
Try higher-value treats (real meat, cheese, hot dog pieces). Train before meals when the dog is hungrier. Some dogs are more toy or play-motivated — use a quick tug game as a reward instead. If your dog suddenly loses all food interest, consult your vet.
Are freeze-dried treats better than soft treats?
They’re higher value due to stronger scent, but they take slightly longer to eat and create crumbs. Use freeze-dried for challenging environments (outdoors, around other dogs) and soft treats for indoor, low-distraction training. Having both in your training pouch gives you flexibility.
Training works best with a healthy, energetic dog. Feed quality food as the foundation — our puppy food guide covers nutrition for dogs in training age. For dogs pulling on leash during training walks, see our picks for keeping dogs entertained between sessions.
Pet Product Specialist & Veterinary Nutrition Consultant
Sarah has spent over 8 years reviewing pet products and consulting with veterinarians to help pet owners make informed choices. She shares her home with two rescue dogs, a senior cat, and a very opinionated parrot. Her reviews combine hands-on testing with science-backed research.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.